Skip to main content
Level 4
April 6, 2023
Question

ROTH CONTRIBUTION RECHARACTERIZED BEFORE DUE DATE OF RETURN

  • April 6, 2023
  • 2 replies
  • 36 views

My client funded a Roth in 2022 and could not make a Roth contribution so they have withdrawn it with $165 of earnings. I want to show this on the 2022 return because they will receive a 1099R for 2023 that will put the income back into 2022. Can't figure out which code to use on the 1099R input sheet.  If I put the gross distribution of $6166 in box 1 of 1099R and $166 in box 2a with a code in box 7 of 8 then it brings the income in as earnings on Form 1040 line 1 h. Just not sure that is the proper treatment. Ultimately perhaps it doesn't matter but just wondering if anyone else has dealt with this.

This topic has been closed for replies.

2 replies

qbteachmt
Level 15
April 6, 2023

"I want to show this on the 2022 return"

Most common would be 8 and J.

8 is used with code (if applicable): 1, 2, 4, B, or J.

See this article:

https://proconnect.intuit.com/support/en-us/help-article/insurance-medical-benefits/understanding-form-1099-r-distribution-codes/L07uc1vzw_US_en_US?uid=lg5k8b4g

Don't forget if there is early distribution penalty, if the person is under 59 1/2, etc. Form 8606 for basis, form 5329:

https://proconnect.intuit.com/support/en-us/help-article/federal-taxes/entering-form-1099-r-proseries/L0otcKvVi_US_en_US?uid=lg5k6j2c

 

Don't yell at us; we're volunteers
DebiHCPAAuthor
Level 4
April 6, 2023

The problem is there is not a choice for trying to correct this before the return is filed. I will have to force the program to come out with the correct solution.

rbynaker
Level 13
April 6, 2023

For data entry, if it's going to be a 2023 1099-R with a code P enter it in 2022 as a 2022 code P and scroll down a wee bit to check the box for "2023 1099 received with code P" (or something like that) and it should work like magic.

Edit: It used to be box A 5, maybe it still is.

rbynaker
Level 13
April 6, 2023

I always have to look this up.  First I'm going to pick on you about terminology.  This doesn't sound like a recharacterization.  That's when you get to "rewrite history" and pretend this went into a Traditional IRA instead of a Roth (or vice versa).  Sounds like what you have is a corrective distribution.

If you're lucky you can get the broker to tell you what 1099(s) they're going to issue and what amounts and codes they're going to put on them.  If this is a 2023 1099-R with a code P for $6,166 / $166 then go ahead and enter it in 2022 so you don't have to amend later.  As Michelle said, there might be a penalty on the earnings.  I *think* that's what I would expect (because the excess contribution was made in 2022) but peruse the 1099-R instructions to see if you can figure out if this should be taxable in 2022 or 2023.

The other alternative is a 2023 1099-R with a code 8 which is taxable in 2023.  I *think* that's what happens when you make a Jan 2023 excess Roth IRA contribution but designate it for 2022, then fix it in March 2023.  But it's April 6th and I reserve the right to be remembering this all wrong. 🙂

Rick