Level 10

Solved

Home improvements medically necessary

Forum|Forum|2 years ago
April 24, 2024
3 replies
17 views

Taxpayer spent 150K on medically necessary home improvements in 2023. He did not get an appraisal before, and he did not get an appraisal after. He knows that there will be no increase in the assessed value by the county tax assessor (through a friend who works for the county.) Is this sufficient corroborating evidence to show no increase in value for the medical deduction?

Lacerte Tax

This topic has been closed for replies.

Best answer by BobKamman

Of course not. It has nothing to do with property tax assessments, especially when you have a friend at the county. A real estate agent might be a good source. Two or three of them, even better.

BobKammanAnswer

Level 15

Of course not. It has nothing to do with property tax assessments, especially when you have a friend at the county. A real estate agent might be a good source. Two or three of them, even better.

S

strongsilenceAuthor

Level 10

We are going with the RE agent report - before and after. Will be some 100s of bucks, but it is worth it.

Lift, ramp, handles were the biggest improvements.

The medical improvements make it less attractive for the general population of homebuyer such as families.

A RE tax assessment generally correlates, or tracks, the fair value sale price and could be viewed as a proxy for an actual agent report. I don't think that argument would win but lacking any other evidence, it could.

Thanks to you and everyone else who replied.

abctax55

Level 15

@strongsilence

" ...A RE tax assessment generally correlates, or tracks, the fair value sale price"

That may apply in your state and probably many more, but it most definitely doesn't apply in California (due to Prop 13). My house is 'valued' on our property tax statement at $ 140,000. We could sell it for a bit more than that 😉

HumanKind... Be Both

IRonMaN

Level 15

Does the friend at the county know a good barber that your client can get some advice from? Out of an abundance of curiosity, what did the client spend $150K on that won't have any effect on the value of the home?

Slava Ukraini!

BobKamman

Level 15

I had a client who installed a system that would use a lift to carry a patient from bedroom to bathroom. Another client installed an elevator from the basement, where an elderly parent had separate living quarters, to the ground floor. In the first case, the improvements were removed before the house was sold, because they actually decreased the value of the home.

IRonMaN

Level 15

I said I was curious, I didn't say it was impossible. 😁

Slava Ukraini!

S

strongsilenceAuthor

Level 10

UPDATE:

The appraisal report arrived, and it showed an increase in FMV of $75,000. This resulted in a medical deduction of $144K. For a tax savings of $15,000.

(Sadly, the improvements were made for his son, who passed away a few weeks after the improvements were finished.)

Sign up

Login with SSO

Let's get you signed in

Login with SSO

Scanning file for viruses.

This file cannot be downloaded